Remarks by Commissioner McGrath in the European Parliament on the Rule of Law in Malta
Dear Chair, Honourable Members,
Thank you for holding this debate to commemorate the ninth anniversary of the assassination of Daphne Caruana Galizia. Daphne was a courageous Maltese investigative journalist, known for her determined and fearless reporting. Her assassination shook all of us. Her murder robbed her family and friends of a loved one, including her three sons Matthew, Paul and Andrew, and society of a courageous journalist who dedicated her life to exposing corruption and holding power to account. It was an attack on journalism and on democracy itself. The Commission has consistently called for all those responsible for this assassination to be brought to justice. There needs to be accountability. There can be no impunity for this atrocious crime and judicial procedures are still ongoing.
Sadly, Daphne was not the only journalist in Europe to pay with her life for her work. Just four months later, in February 2018, Jan Kuciak was murdered in Slovakia, together with his fiancée, Martina Kušnírová. He too was investigating fraud and corruption. And this year marks thirty years since Veronica Guerin was shot dead in Dublin, in my own country, Ireland, because of her reporting on organised crime. I still remember the shock when the news broke. It is a moment Ireland has never forgotten. The protection of media and journalists remains a political priority across the European Union. For our part, in the years following Daphne's assassination, we have taken concrete action to uphold media freedom and to protect journalists.
We have recommended wide-ranging measures to ensure the protection, safety and empowerment of journalists and other media professionals. New EU legislative rules are in place to protect journalists and civil society from abusive lawsuits. And we have enshrined a comprehensive regime to protect media freedom and media pluralism under the European Media Freedom Act (EMFA). We are working with Member States to ensure that this framework delivers on the ground. Furthermore, the European Democracy Shield – published in November last year – seeks to further support journalists and enhance their protection against undue pressure and threats.
As regards the situation of the rule of law in Malta, since 2020 the Commission is closely monitoring developments in the context of the annual Rule of Law Reports. I would like to thank the Maltese authorities and stakeholders for the good cooperation throughout the annual rule of law cycle. The 2026 edition of the Rule of Law Report, published in July, contains an in-depth analysis of the main developments regarding the rule of law in Malta. The Report notes that Malta has taken certain steps to address some of issues identified, but that further efforts are needed to address the recommendations of the European Commission.
Looking at the situation of media freedom and pluralism, the Rule of Law Report noted limited progress on adopting safeguards to improve the working environment of journalists, including access to official documents. The Commission is aware that the Maltese government has announced the tabling of a comprehensive media reform in the coming weeks. In that context, it will be important that Malta ensures adequate consultation of relevant stakeholders. The Commission will analyse this legislation once adopted, including in the light of the requirements of the European Media Freedom Act (EMFA). The Commission is also aware of the government's intention to expand the protection of journalists and others acting as public watchdogs against abusive lawsuits, so-called SLAPPs.
Malta was the first Member State to transpose the Anti-SLAPP Directive in 2024 covering cross-border cases. In its anti-SLAPP Recommendation, the Commission called on all Member States to extend the protection also to domestic cases. I very much hope that Malta will take the opportunity now enact such an extension to domestic cases.
On the justice system, the Commission recommended to Malta to take forward initiatives to increase resources, reform court procedures, and advance digitalisation with a view to improving the efficiency of the justice system, as no further progress had been reported in this year's Report. Efficiency of justice is crucial for effective judicial protection of citizens and businesses and for strengthening trust in the justice system. The Report also recommended taking forward reforms with a view to involve the judiciary in the procedure for the appointment of the Chief Justice. This reform is still pending, and the political debate is ongoing.
With regard to the fight against corruption, the Report noted that progress remains to be achieved on establishing a robust track record of final judgments in corruption cases, given the high backlog of pending court cases, judges' workload and that a limited team of four magistrates are responsible for handling preliminary inquiries. The Report also noted that limited progress was made to address challenges related to the length of investigations of high-level corruption cases and recommended stepping up efforts in this regard.
Finally, as regards other checks and balances, the Report notes that Malta made limited progress in introducing a formal framework for public participation in the legislative process. Since legislative reforms remain pending, it is recommended to Malta to introduce such a framework. Moreover, the report called on Malta to establish a National Human Rights Institution, as a legislative proposal to that end remains under preparation.
In conclusion, the Commission continues to insist on the need to make further progress on the different pending issues highlighted in the recommendations of this year's Rule of Law Report. The Commission remains committed to support Malta in these efforts.
Thank you.
| Zařazeno | čt 22.10.2026 16:10:15 |
|---|---|
| Vydáno | |
| Zdroj | Evropská komise en |
| Originál | ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/api/documents?reference=STATEMENT/26/2241&language=en |
| lang | en |
| guid | /STATEMENT/26/2241/ |